S
cotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have joined forces in a new push for constitutional change, with their nationalist and pro-reunification leaders calling for greater self-determination and expressing an ambition to return to the European Union.
The leaders of the Scottish National Party (SNP), Plaid Cymru and Sinn Féin signed a joint memorandum in Cardiff on Sept. 13 asserting what they described as the right of the three nations to determine their own constitutional futures.
The meeting was attended by Scotland’s First Minister John Swinney, Wales’ First Minister Rhun ap Iorwerth, Northern Ireland’s First Minister Michelle O’Neill and Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald.
The memorandum calls on the British government to “prepare for and facilitate constitutional change,” arguing that Westminster should not prevent citizens from deciding their own political future.
At the center of the document is a call for referendums that would allow voters in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland to determine their respective constitutional arrangements.
The three nations, however, are pursuing different objectives. Scotland is seeking another independence referendum following the 2014 vote, when 55.3% of voters chose to remain part of the United Kingdom. Wales is advocating what its leaders describe as a “constitutional path” toward independence without setting a specific timetable.
Northern Ireland’s case is different, focusing on the possibility of reunification with the Republic of Ireland rather than independence as a separate state.
The memorandum represents a convergence between political movements that have historically pursued separate constitutional agendas. The article describes the current situation as significant because the governments of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland are led by parties that support independence or Irish reunification.
The initiative nevertheless faces opposition from the British government, which continues to support the United Kingdom’s territorial union.
A shared element of the three movements is their support for closer ties with the European Union. The memorandum states that the “future of our nations lies in the European Union” and argues that Brexit has damaged their economies.
The leaders’ position reflects a broader disagreement with the decision taken by the United Kingdom in the 2016 Brexit referendum. According to the article, the UK’s departure from the EU has contributed to stronger support among some political movements in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland for pursuing a different constitutional and European path.
The British government has rejected the latest calls for constitutional change. Prime Minister Andy Burnham reiterated his “strong support for the Union” and opposed the proposals advanced by the nationalist leaders.
Burnham said the government should concentrate on economic security rather than opening new constitutional debates.
The question of Scottish independence remains particularly contentious. Westminster continues to oppose a second independence referendum, while Scotland’s nationalist leadership maintains its demand for another vote.
Northern Ireland operates under a different constitutional framework. The Good Friday Agreement provides for the possibility of a referendum on Irish reunification if there is sufficient evidence that a majority of people in Northern Ireland would support such a change.
Recommended
The debate over Northern Ireland’s future also received international attention during U.S. President Donald Trump’s visit to Dublin.
Trump said he would like to see the island of Ireland united and argued that such a development would eventually take place. He described Irish unity as potentially beneficial and said he believed it would be difficult to see how it could be a negative outcome.
During his remarks, Trump also referred to Irish Prime Minister Micheál Martin, suggesting that he could play a role in starting the process.
The comments add an international dimension to an already sensitive constitutional debate. The prospect of Irish reunification remains a politically divisive issue in Northern Ireland, particularly between nationalist communities that favor unity with the Republic of Ireland and unionists who want to remain part of the United Kingdom.
The new memorandum from Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland does not establish a timetable for constitutional change, and the three territories face different legal and political processes.
For Scotland and Wales, the central question is independence from the United Kingdom, while Northern Ireland’s constitutional future is governed in part by the arrangements established under the Good Friday Agreement.
The leaders’ joint initiative nevertheless signals a common political emphasis on self-determination and closer European integration. Whether the proposals can advance will depend on political developments in Westminster, public support in the three nations and the distinct constitutional mechanisms governing each part of the United Kingdom.
(Source: Euro News)
Stay informed by subscribing to
our weekly newsletter.
